1. Check out our companion app, Forums for Android! Download from Google Play

Why do so many popular apps access personal info?

Discussion in 'Android Apps & Games' started by boogbooga, May 22, 2011.

  1. boogbooga

    boogbooga New Member
    Thread Starter
    5

    May 22, 2011
    3
    0
    5
    Hi there, I'm new to the Android scene but I've noticed that alot of apps need access to your personal information. Even popular ones like launcherpro and lookout want access to all that. Is there a reason for this or am I being paranoid?
     

    Advertisement

  2. sdrawkcab25

    sdrawkcab25 Well-Known Member
    423

    Aug 5, 2010
    5,587
    2,005
    423
    Male
    PA
    It's necessary for those types of apps to work, especially launchers like launcher pro.
     
    boogbooga likes this.
  3. boogbooga

    boogbooga New Member
    Thread Starter
    5

    May 22, 2011
    3
    0
    5
    So lookout needs to read/edit my SMS and all the calls I make? It just seems fishy to me thats all.
     
  4. euph_22

    euph_22 Well-Known Member
    213

    Feb 24, 2010
    2,634
    595
    213
    Grad Student (Applied/Computational Math)
    Milwaukee, WI
    boogbooga likes this.
  5. boogbooga

    boogbooga New Member
    Thread Starter
    5

    May 22, 2011
    3
    0
    5
  6. iowabowtech

    iowabowtech root@android:/ #
    1,493

    May 2, 2010
    12,170
    8,669
    1,493
    Making the Establishment nervous
    Iowa|USA
    Lookout is kind of an interesting one because of its very intent you are pretty much placing your faith in that app in order to protect your interests. You are wise to question permissions in general though. I think many people, myself sometimes included, don't pay enough attention to them.
     
  7. NightAngel79

    NightAngel79 Bounty Hunter Administrator
    Moderator
    1,433

    May 11, 2010
    22,432
    7,809
    1,433
    Male
    Systems Administrator
    Northern Ky
    moved to Android lounge
     
  8. mikedt

    mikedt 你好
    2,238

    Sep 22, 2010
    20,993
    10,902
    2,238
    Teachaaa
    Jinan, China
    At least the Lookout people are up-front and explain why they need those permissions.

    I'm always extremely suspicious and would never install things like wallpaper apps or shoot 'em up games which require GPS position, phone calls, SMS, contacts, etc. I bet so many people don't even look at or question an app's permissions, and just install everything willy nilly.
     
  9. takeshi

    takeshi Well-Known Member
    163

    Dec 6, 2009
    3,354
    282
    163
    There is a fine line between questioning permissions and going all tinfoil hat without actually understanding the permissions though. If you don't understand why an app is asking for a permission then ask for help in understanding why. Sometime's it's not so straightforward that you can rely just on the name of the permission. Be skeptical but don't swing too far in the opposite direction either.
     
  10. odhinn

    odhinn Well-Known Member
    16

    Jan 28, 2010
    75
    9
    16
    Most apps will ask for the moon, knowing the only choice you have is to install or not install. I switched from Pandora to Stitcher when Pandora started requiring access to my contact list and calendar - a music player doesn't need access to that information to play music. If you contact Pandora, they will tell you they need that access to create events (e.g. concerts) or share songs with your friends. Sure, fine, whatever.

    The problem is, even if you trust the application to not abuse your data, you have no recourse if you don't.

    This is why so many people have requested Google give users the ability to choose what permissions an app is given. So the app can still ask for the moon, but you as the user can decide if you want to give the application that level of permissions or not. e.g. install Pandora, but tell it no you can't access my contact database or calendar.

    Naturally, Google does not want to do this, because they are afraid of people blocking internet access for some apps, e.g. Angry Birds, and suddenly the ads are blocked - upsets the application developer, who then stops using Android. However, that's a specious argument since there is obviously a way to satisfy most users while still allowing ads to be displayed to satisfy most application developers and advertisers.

    If you, like me, feel Google should listen to its users and give the user the power to choose what sorts of access applications have to your data, spread the word about this issue. Note comment #44 where a Google employee specifically states this is the most requested feature, and that they are not going to fix it.

    Issue 3778 - android - Feature request: Application permissions should be individually grantable by the user - Android - An Open Handset Alliance Project - Google Project Hosting
     
    tempmail and AndroidSPCS like this.
  11. sonofaresiii

    sonofaresiii Well-Known Member
    68

    Apr 9, 2011
    500
    49
    68
    NYC
    Christ, what's with all the paranoia? Do people really think there's a secret underground Evil, Inc. company somewhere whose master plan is to release an app to track your personal location so they can send their black ops agents out to kidnap you? I mean what's the fear? And where are you people finding these sketchy apps in the first place? I assure you, fancywidgets has no interest in hacking your phone, stealing your address and robbing your house. They just want to make your phone look nifty.
     
    KENNECTED likes this.
  12. AndroidSPCS

    AndroidSPCS Well-Known Member
    183

    Nov 12, 2009
    3,222
    478
    183
    geek
    USA
    Your rant is quite over the top and pointless.

    Do you TRULY know that apps have no interest in hacking the phone and stealing info??? Do you personally vet every single app?
     
    tempmail and odhinn like this.
  13. mikedt

    mikedt 你好
    2,238

    Sep 22, 2010
    20,993
    10,902
    2,238
    Teachaaa
    Jinan, China
    Erm... the Android Market... many apps there with highly questionable permissions. Wallpaper which wants GPS location info, flashlights(turns the screen white) which wants contacts and messaging information, space invaders games which requires full internet access and well as contact information .. When I see stuff like this, no wonder I'm careful about what I install.
     
  14. AndroidSPCS

    AndroidSPCS Well-Known Member
    183

    Nov 12, 2009
    3,222
    478
    183
    geek
    USA
    I'm particularly concerned about contacts / calendar access. How do I know if an app doesn't change my contacts or change my calendar? :thinking:

    Not to mention the risk of sensitive data being leaked out. :mad:
     
  15. sonofaresiii

    sonofaresiii Well-Known Member
    68

    Apr 9, 2011
    500
    49
    68
    NYC
    I think I brought up some legitimate points. I genuinely don't understand what people are afraid of. Someone can get your address by following you home, too, and far more easily than finding a security issue with android... but people don't get upset that there aren't government-issued body guards for everyone.

    I find it far more likely that someone's going to break into your car and steal your phone, than that an app will do.... *something* to you, though no one can really tell me what they're afraid of.

    So, again, what's with all the paranoia? It's a legitimate question. Why are people so worried?
     
  16. bluenova

    bluenova OK Computer
    143

    Jan 11, 2010
    1,617
    243
    143
    Driver
    W Midlands, UK
    Perhaps identity theft and credit card fraud is not as big in your neck of the woods as it is over here but it happens all the time over here and mostly by people being socially engineered or just plain careless with their security on internet enabled devices (mainly using the same password across sites). It's amazing what a criminal can then do with a little information.

    For a thief to target one person (old school thiefing) it is very inefficient and the chances of that target becoming fruitful is not very high. By using websites/apps or hacking say Sonys database a thief can obtain information on multiple targets making the chances of fruition much higher.
     
    tempmail, odhinn and AndroidSPCS like this.
  17. tempmail

    16

    Jan 4, 2011
    20
    5
    16
    A lot of people are actually storing personal information on their phones. Information that they do not want to make available to random app developers.

    Maybe you do not mind that unknown people can read all your SMS and email and log all your surfing, but many people do.

    Heck, a lot of people would not even let their coworkers access all their personal data, even though they know them personally. E.g. you might let your coworkers read your work related emails but you do not want them to read your personal emails to your children.

    I find it annoying that certain people mindlessly pull out the "Paranoid!" card when important security aspects are being discussed.

    http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=3778#c90
     
  18. ElasticNinja

    ElasticNinja Well-Known Member
    183

    Aug 29, 2010
    4,488
    472
    183
    Student
    Cork City, IMF, EU
    If you are running Nightly 83+ of CM7 you can restrict permissions :)
     
  19. Lennatron

    Lennatron Well-Known Member
    73

    Oct 2, 2010
    451
    98
    73
    Male
    College Student
    PA
    Does anyone know why all games need internet access? I know some games need it so you can play people online or submit high scores, but most games need internet access but they don't do any of these things.
     
  20. sdrawkcab25

    sdrawkcab25 Well-Known Member
    423

    Aug 5, 2010
    5,587
    2,005
    423
    Male
    PA

    Usually for ads to work.
     
  21. NightAngel79

    NightAngel79 Bounty Hunter Administrator
    Moderator
    1,433

    May 11, 2010
    22,432
    7,809
    1,433
    Male
    Systems Administrator
    Northern Ky
    I also would have guessed so they can check market for updates
     
  22. ElasticNinja

    ElasticNinja Well-Known Member
    183

    Aug 29, 2010
    4,488
    472
    183
    Student
    Cork City, IMF, EU
    uh why would they need that NA?
     
  23. NightAngel79

    NightAngel79 Bounty Hunter Administrator
    Moderator
    1,433

    May 11, 2010
    22,432
    7,809
    1,433
    Male
    Systems Administrator
    Northern Ky
    How else would an app/market know if you have an update available??
     
  24. ElasticNinja

    ElasticNinja Well-Known Member
    183

    Aug 29, 2010
    4,488
    472
    183
    Student
    Cork City, IMF, EU
    The Market checks itself for updates
     
  25. NightAngel79

    NightAngel79 Bounty Hunter Administrator
    Moderator
    1,433

    May 11, 2010
    22,432
    7,809
    1,433
    Male
    Systems Administrator
    Northern Ky
    Link? Not that i doubt you because that does make sense, but my explanation also made sense (to me at least:p)
     

Share This Page

Loading...