I've tried both, but I use Handcent for one reason: I like its popup window better.

 

I hate handcent, ugly name, ugly icon, Slow.

 

the only comparison i can think of is: handcent = iphone, chomp = android.

i used handcent for an hour (if that) before switching to chomp and i havent looked back since!

 

I've tried both, and the customization of Handcent was more so than Chompsms. I like the choice of choosing the way the texts show up. (e.i. Iphone, Android, Handcent)

 

I've tried both Handcent and ChompSMS, but stick with Handcent personally. ChompSMS has that ugly add bar at the top, and if you want to get rid of it, you have to pay $3.50 to get rid of it. $3.50 and you don't get anything except the removal of the add bar. Terrible.

To top it all off, it has maybe half the features of Handcent.

 

Because someone skinned a few aspects of handcent to match the blue swype trail (the area around text boxes, the grey color, etc.) just for me =D

I have the .apk if anyone wants it.

 

Yeah handscent is way better I don't know how people could use chomp it lacks so much and plus that ad bar is so annoying makes it look ugly. So my opinion is pick handscent over chomp you wont regret it.

Sent from my Eris using Tapatalk

 

Well. I like Handcent for it's customizations and options, but Chomp's widget is pretty nice. If you want a pretty basic messaging app, go with default Android messaging. Not HTC's but stock Android. I ported it so it will install and work on an unrooted phone running 2.1. Any of the leaks.

http://androidforums.com/htc-droid-eris/81225-vanilla-mms-ported-non-rooted.html

And you're welcome BlueDC2. I think I did that. I can't even remember now.

 

Never tried Chomps. Someone suggested Handcent and I like it so no need to try anything different.

Your avatar reminds me of the Unibomber police sketches. Not sure you know of him though.

 

The only way I'll use that mms app is if the double received message gets fixed any idea on when that's gonna be fixed

Sent from my Eris using Tapatalk

 

I doubt it will. It's not really that annoying. It's not like it notifies you twice, just for some reason shows up twice when you look in the thread. It's so much smoother than any other mms app, but I mean if it bothers you.

It's not an app problem, because I've ported about 10 different versions that work perfectly on other phones. The problem lies within the HTC messaging app with the combination of the stock Android mms app. It's showing up twice in Handcent, Chomp, HTC, and stock Android as long as it's installed.

I believe it could be fixed changing the code up a bit so it won't deliver messages with the HTC app and this app, that's why two is showing up. I'm just not that skilled with it, and I can't find where the problem is at exactly.

 

Last time I tried Chomp, I couldn't get it to light my trackball for notifications, whereas Handcent can. Has this been fixed?

 

Nope, still LED only.

 

Been with Handcent since I first tried it. I gave Chomp a try shortly after giving handcent a try, but wasn't a fan.

 

Yeah, I was going to link to the thread if anyone wanted it. Giving redit where credit is due, it looks sooo clean!

 

Buddy of mine told me about handcent when I first picked up my eris a few weeks back and have been using it since. Works fine for me.

 

The feel of it.
I can just feel it, Y'know?

 

I have tried both, just installed Chomp today.

Handcent:
Pros:
-very customizable
-unread count
-pop up

Cons:
-can't resize pictures to send SMS, I always have to send pictures via stock Messages

Chomp:
Pros:
-can set lock screen so only you can access your messages
-customizable
-don't have to worry about pictures resizing

Cons:
-ads do make it look cheap
-no unread count


To each their own.

 

Handcent resizes my photos just fine.

 

Good to hear it works well for someone else, might be the case for everyone else. For my wife and I we can never get it to resize the pictures correctly, just goes thru the motions of resizing it and then says it is still too big to send. So then we always have to send it out via stock Messages, go figure.

 

Have you tried the settings option to "limit message size" to a larger size? I thinly thats what did it for me... if I remember right.

 

Resize works fine for me. I've been using handcent since December, faithfully. Love it!

@Romparoo - I, however, consistently have it fail to resize any pic I've taken at maximum high level settings. Try taking a pic at like 3M or 1M and see if you can send it.

Otherwise, PicSayPro is a nice and FREE alternative with a swift resize/crop feature.

 

I've had problems with Handcent keeping my phone awake. I would consider that a con to be added to this list.

And, there is an unread count in Chomp. Go into Chomp, Menu>Settings>Notifications>Notification Icon Count. That will display the number of unread messages you have.

I will gladly pay (and did) the three dollars for getting rid of the Chomp ads. It's giving the developer reason to keep making the app better, if he keeps making it better he keeps getting more money.

I just had problems with Handcent. I liked the trackball lighting up, but that's really the only thing I miss from Handcent. I never used the pop up feature, and it turned my screen on if my phone was asleep, which I use with Chomp anyways. Besides, there are ads in Handcent in the menus. Maybe that was why the battery drained and the phone stayed awake? Some glitch with the ads in the menus updating or something?