1. Check out our companion app, Forums for Android! Download from Google Play

Root Why you shouldn't root your phone

Discussion in 'Android Devices' started by bzzzzz, Feb 11, 2010.

  1. bzzzzz

    bzzzzz Well-Known Member
    Thread Starter
    36

    Dec 27, 2009
    155
    2
    36
    teacher
    uk
    There are quite a few threads waxing lyrical about the advantages of rooting your phone, I haven't heard too many people saying why you shouldn't do it.

    Are there any good reasons to not root your phone?
    Has anyone got any horror stories of rooting their phone and having heaps of trouble. I'd be interested to find out.

    My instinct is that by rooting your phone your essentially giving yourself admin permission on your phone. Whilst useful, I suspect that this comes with security risks. I've heard that some jailbroken iphones managed to pick up viruses.
     

    Advertisement

  2. vjprakashbe

    vjprakashbe Well-Known Member
    36

    Nov 24, 2009
    182
    9
    36
    Bangalore
    ll void your warranty ::)
     
  3. phillevy

    phillevy Well-Known Member
    63

    Aug 27, 2009
    501
    15
    63
    Ongar, UK
    Arguably not - however that would only be if you returned it rooted. It is a simple matter to reverse the process.
     
  4. poultrum

    poultrum Well-Known Member
    16

    Nov 20, 2009
    64
    4
    16
    technician
    england
    I`d say biggest reason not to, is that even though the dev for most roms know what their doing i`m sure theirs small parts of coding,that only htc know about, which may look like nothing to most dev but make a huge differance to performance and experience, and with the new 2.1 i`d say htc will be making huge changes from the standard to get it running perfect for that phone, plus i`m pretty sure HTC and the rest do a hell of alot more beta testing in a proffesional environment, than the dev`s
    soley as they have more money
     
  5. Xyro

    Xyro 4 8 15 16 23 42
    Moderator
    1,413

    Dec 1, 2009
    12,868
    9,180
    1,413
    UK
    In my experience custom ROMs are a mixed bag in terms of performance. Some aren't really stable enough to use normaly, like a few of the 2.1 + sense ones I've tried. But on the other hand, some ROMs can out perform HTC's version. MoDaCo 3.1 for example, is a much smoother experience than the stock ROM.
     
  6. phillevy

    phillevy Well-Known Member
    63

    Aug 27, 2009
    501
    15
    63
    Ongar, UK
    Since the OP is about rooting, this is being confused with the topic (although related) of custom ROMs. You can root the original ROM to be able to use particular apps (eg louder volume, titanium backup), without having to touch a custom ROM.
     
  7. daveybaby

    daveybaby Well-Known Member
    93

    Sep 21, 2009
    919
    105
    93
    Software engineer
    UK
    Here's a question to anyone knowledgable about such things: i am meaning to root my phone at some point and install a custom ROM (probably modaco). I'm wondering if i should do it now, i.e. before the official 2.1 is released, in case HTC have closed whatever loopholes allow the phone to be rooted.

    How likely/feasible is this? Are there ways to root that HTC *cant* block, or are cleverer people than me just going to have to find new ways in (as they invariably and rapidly do for the iphone after each firmware update)?
     
  8. jaybea830802

    jaybea830802 Well-Known Member
    18

    Jul 24, 2009
    90
    10
    18
    Manchester, UK
    Paul from MoDaCo has suggested that you should not install 2.1 when it does appear for just this reason - Google may well have closed the loopholes which allow root access in 1.5. I am sure that someone will find a way to get root access eventually, but it may take a while.
     
  9. vido.ardes

    vido.ardes Well-Known Member
    163

    Oct 17, 2009
    1,059
    200
    163
    Software Developer
    Kent, UK
    It is worth noting there is a clear distinction between rooting and running a custom ROM.

    Rooting enables you to get access to parts of the system you didn't before, so you can install apps the require root access (ShootMe for screenshots, Titanium Backup for backing up apps).

    Running a custom ROM requires root access, but involves completely removing the software on your phone and replacing it with a totally custom version of the software, not endorsed by HTC or Google.
     
  10. phillevy

    phillevy Well-Known Member
    63

    Aug 27, 2009
    501
    15
    63
    Ongar, UK
    Just what I said earlier!
     
  11. phillevy

    phillevy Well-Known Member
    63

    Aug 27, 2009
    501
    15
    63
    Ongar, UK
    I've always been amazed at this - seems to fly in the face of something being open-source:(
     
  12. daveybaby

    daveybaby Well-Known Member
    93

    Sep 21, 2009
    919
    105
    93
    Software engineer
    UK
    Ah, ok, thanks. Hopefully a MoDaCo based on 2.1 will be out soon after the official release, which will maintain root access.

    Hmmm... maybe this has spurred me into action. Might do a bit of rooting this weekend (fnarrr).
     
  13. phillevy

    phillevy Well-Known Member
    63

    Aug 27, 2009
    501
    15
    63
    Ongar, UK
    I'm hoping Paul's version might be out beforehand if previous "leaks" are anything to go by:)
     
  14. Xyro

    Xyro 4 8 15 16 23 42
    Moderator
    1,413

    Dec 1, 2009
    12,868
    9,180
    1,413
    UK
    Even if there isn't a leak, over on Modaco forums they seem pretty confident they can turn the official 2.1 RUU into a normal .zip the very same day. So no need to risk having rooting blocked.
     
  15. Arthur Hucksake

    Arthur Hucksake Well-Known Member
    16

    Feb 3, 2010
    68
    3
    16
    I guess the main thing to worry about is whether your phone is branded to high hell by your provider. If that's the case and it needs a repair they might get suspect as to why certain things are missing.

    I find that most of the time though (well in the UK anyways) they are just sending out HTC Hero's with the odd shortcut up on the home screen that can be deleted without suspicion and no horrible obstructive changes like i've seen with many symbian phones.

    Rooting and custom roms are definately the way to go though, your never look back. Really does improve them, for a start it makes them snappier and give you more freedom to toy with your phone.
     
  16. vikingisson

    vikingisson Well-Known Member
    83

    Getting back on topic, why not root?

    . you have no compelling reason to. saying you're rooted doesn't impress us.
    . you don't like the risk of bricking. It can happen.
    . you like to call the provider for problems.

    that being said, mine is rooted and updated and I don't want to go back to crippleware. But I don't casually suggest everyone do it.
     
  17. PXUmais

    PXUmais Member
    15

    Feb 14, 2010
    20
    0
    15
    Rooting had a very small chance of bricking the phone and anyway rooting will allow apps like wifi tether to work and will also allow custom roms to be installed, these together should overpower the reasons not to.

    The only real reason a person wouldn't root is because they were scared because it would void their guarantee

    BTW - Wifi Tether for root users is an awesome app.
     
  18. snox187

    snox187 Well-Known Member
    36

    Dec 2, 2009
    114
    1
    36
    would love to root but if your phone was stolen and it was rooted could your network still render the phone useless , just got phone stolen once and network blocked phone , i would not like to get stolen and have some scum bag still using the phone cos i rooted it
     
  19. Slug

    Slug Check six!
    Moderator
    2,043

    Aug 1, 2009
    20,553
    16,987
    2,043
    Male
    Mobile phone retail
    Inverness, UK
    Yup, as the IEMI number remains the same and that's what is blocked to prevent use on the network.

    Or because they have no need of any additional functionality gained from rooting. Or they're not interested in third-party ROMs. Or they simply can't be bothered with the hassle. There's no rule that says one has to root. ;)
     
  20. daveybaby

    daveybaby Well-Known Member
    93

    Sep 21, 2009
    919
    105
    93
    Software engineer
    UK
    If you've rooted it and installed something like the MoDaCo ROM, which has wavesecure embedded in it then you can lock down the phone remotely yourself. And track its location. And back up your data from it. And erase your data from it.

    Obviously you can install wavesecure without rooting, but installing a custom ROM with it built in means that it cant be removed even with a factory reset. Point being, rooting can give you more security, not less.
     
  21. pbp776

    pbp776 Well-Known Member
    36

    Feb 2, 2010
    92
    2
    36
    Piscataway, NJ
    This is the main reason I'm holding my self back from not rooting my phone.

    Is there a way Sprint can determine if the phone was rooted and it was reverse to original stock ROM?

    pbp
     
  22. MrClean

    MrClean Well-Known Member
    73

    Jan 27, 2010
    274
    73
    73
    Male
    Telecom
    KC MO
    To my knowledge no and most likely if there was a way, I don't believe 99% of the store employees would know how to find out. I know Sprint uses a 3rd party to insure their phones with, so I doubt the store employee would really care as long as when you took it in for service/replacement it appeared as though it was the original ROM.
     
  23. alchemistkevin

    alchemistkevin Well-Known Member
    36

    Feb 15, 2010
    76
    3
    36
    IT
    London
    wow! nice thread, been wondering about rooting & ROM'ing my new Hero - only holding back coz the stock firmware is quite stable and not crippled like some symbian phones.
     
  24. pbp776

    pbp776 Well-Known Member
    36

    Feb 2, 2010
    92
    2
    36
    Piscataway, NJ
    MrClean, thanks for answer the my question!!!!. I don't have any issue with the phone just the battery life is kind of weak imho. I charge every day before going to sleep 11PM, by morning it is already down to 90 and sometimes around 80ish. Not sure if that normal for battery. This is the main reason I want to see if rooting my phone would be good to gain more battery life.
     
  25. alchemistkevin

    alchemistkevin Well-Known Member
    36

    Feb 15, 2010
    76
    3
    36
    IT
    London
    I wouldn't bet on that - battery life is dependent on the amount of tasks your phone is performing - internet access, etc.

    You probably need an extended battery
     
Tags:

Share This Page

Loading...