1. Are you ready for the Galaxy S20? Here is everything we know so far!

Would you ever buy a phone with a bigger screen than 4.3in??

Discussion in 'Android Lounge' started by droiderg, Oct 4, 2011.


Would you buy a phone with a bigger screen then 4.3in?

  1. yes

    31 vote(s)
  2. no

    17 vote(s)
  1. droiderg

    droiderg Newbie
    Thread Starter

    I recently own a Droid X.
    I love the 4.3 big screen and wish it could be alittle wider.

    My question is

    Do you prefer a big screen phones?
    Any word on the next big screen upcoming phone thats worth waiting for?
    i know the thunderbolt and Bionic is out with 4.3 screens.
    is there any phone thats coming out with a bigger screen then 4.3?


    1. Download the Forums for Android™ app!


  2. 2003vstrom

    2003vstrom Android Enthusiast

    yeah i`m wishing for the sprint Epic 4G touch(sam G2) on ATT with LTE, I guess I can keep on wishing:D
  3. droiderg

    droiderg Newbie
    Thread Starter

    how bigger is the screens on the epic 4g and sam?
    when were they released?

    i wish i can see a phone with dual 4.3in screens that folder/slide.
  4. Yeahha

    Yeahha Usually off topic

    I would love a phone with a larger screen than mine currently. I think we will get to having larger screens on phone up to 7 inches with phones eventually replacing the 7 inch tablet niche, tablets will keep getting bigger and bigger as well.
  5. afrost55

    afrost55 Newbie

    I'm in the no crowd. I think their is a point when phones just become too big and i think 4.3 is my limit. I mean anything bigger and you might as well go after tablet. imho.
  6. vikingjunior

    vikingjunior Well-Known Member

    It's hard to answer this because it's not the actually screen that's to large it's the overall size of the device that may be to large.

    Google sounds to be answering this issue with button less devices which will free up a lot of real estate.
  7. chrlswltrs

    chrlswltrs Extreme Android User

    I really like a 4" and think that is the perfect size. I would go up to 4.5, but that is it and only if the bezel around the screen was small enough. Won't go smaller than 3.7, but that would be hard to after getting used to larger screens.
  8. cds0699

    cds0699 Android Expert

    I already did, I bought the Epic 4G Touch and it's a 4.52" screen. I won't go any bigger than this though.
  9. Sixel

    Sixel Well-Known Member

    I have a phone that is 4.5 but that's probably my limit. I want to always keep my phone hidden in public and a bigger screen wouldn't help.
  10. chanchan05

    chanchan05 The Doctor

    I have a 4inch screen phone, and have tried a SGS2 with 4.3inch. The experience didnt seem much different. However 4.5 and bigger would seem a bit too much.

    The only problem I can see with staying away from 4inch and bigger phones is that you'd be stuck to mid-range mostly.
  11. Harry2

    Harry2 Extreme Android User

    Maybe 4.5" ... it depends on the design.

    What I mean:
    I've two 4.3" phones. The HTC Desire HD is feeling clumsy and the HTC Sensation is feeling gracefully in hand :)

  12. mikedt

    mikedt 你好

    Probably not, anything bigger might not fit in my pockets comfortably.
  13. pool_shark

    pool_shark Android Expert

    I wanted the Bionic when it was rumored to have a 4.5 inch screen.
  14. B2L

    B2L Android Expert

    Yes definitely, I would be up for it if they made a 7" phone. It seems like I could fit the original Galaxy Tab in my pockets quite easily. :)
  15. Morat

    Morat Well-Known Member

    I'm dribbling over the chance to get a Galaxy Note on my work account to replace my HTC Desire. I already have the SGS2 on my personal account.
  16. jerofld

    jerofld Fixing stuff is not easy

    Having a 7" display phone would be quite ridiculous looking when answering a call by placing one edge to your ear and having the microphone near your throat.

    As for 4.5"+ displays, I'm with most of the others. Only if the actual dimensions of the phone were not too different from current 4.3"-4.5" phones.
  17. ASC

    ASC I'm Shy

    When I first got my Droid X I was a little weary of the screen size. Now that I've had it for almost 18 months, I could definitely go bigger. I have big hands though. I think a 4.7" would be perfect for me and might consider as big as 5" but no bigger. You also have to remember that when the new phones start coming out with ICS pre-installed the devices wont have/need any Physical & Captive buttons, Making room for bigger screen's on the same size devices. So, In reality, we should be talking about device size as well.
  18. John Redcorn

    John Redcorn Android Enthusiast

    HTFY I would! I got a 4.3" inspire and came from a blackjack II (a blackberry form factor winmo phone) and it seemed huge at first to me but now it's just fine and I'd like bigger. Played with a 4.5" infuse in the store, liked, we could go bigger than that!
  19. Shocky

    Shocky Android Expert

    I think another 0.3" would be acceptable, not sure about the 5.3" Galaxy Note though, I think that might be pushing it. :p
  20. download44

    download44 Lurker

    Bigger than 4.3", just get a tablet
  21. novox77

    novox77 Leeeroy Jennnkinnns!

    I think 5" is the max for a phone (super thin bezel), and 7" is the min for a tablet. anything in between is an identity crisis device and won't sell well.

    Someone mentioned removing the hard capacitive buttons. That won't really help. It will just give you a super long/wide screen. I don't think that kind of aspect ratio is pleasant nor useful.
  22. xmr405o

    xmr405o Android Expert

    I wouldn't mind getting a screen bigger than 4.3 just as long as the overall phone size isn't too big. With Android 4.0, increasing the screen size shouldn't be an issue especially if manufacturers do not need to include buttons on the front of the phone.

    Imagine the Bionic, DX, DX2 and even the D3 without capacitive buttons you can easily get another .2 or .5 inches worth of screen real estate without sacrificing the overall phone dimensions.

    That would be sweet!

    Edit: Didn't notice your last sentence, Novox. haha. I respectfully disagree. :eek::p Manufacturers will find a way to make it look right especially when 720p phones come out.

  23. novox77

    novox77 Leeeroy Jennnkinnns!

    Well it's an issue of aspect ratio more than diagonal size. Yes, if the buttons go away, you DO get a bigger screen and a longer diagonal, but you have a very long rectangular shape.

    720p implies a fixed aspect ratio of 16:9. So if you make your phone screen too rectangular, you're going to end up with thick black bars when watching video that's made at 4:3 or 16:9.

    the qHD phones right now are 16:9 already. If you remove the buttons and keep the aspect ratio the same, your phone will get a lot wider. That kinda defeats the purpose of removing the buttons.

    But yeah, I can't wait to have 720p on a 16:9 ~4.3" screen. That's insane pixel density and eye candy :)
  24. Estes0109

    Estes0109 Newbie

    I was thinking about that because these phones to me are just getting too big. I mean dont get me wrong after having the evo I dont want a phone smaller than 4" MAYBE 3.8 but no smaller. BUT bigger than 4.3 for a PHONE is just to big to me. I think we forget the reason we have a phone. I love the new convenience that came with technology but you got to draw a line.

    It's funny to me, I remember my mother's phone was huge back in the day then they start getting smaller now there making them large again of course different type of large but still large. Imagine putting 7" CELL PHONE in your purse...lol...:D
  25. Bob Cat

    Bob Cat Careful, They're sharp!!
    VIP Member

    I'd like a 4.5 and maybe even a 5" but no bigger than that.

Share This Page