It was this exact one from this seller:
Blue Silicone Case For Verizon HTC Droid Incredible - eBay (item 370388118952 end time Jun-27-10 09:07:32 PDT)
But, I'm not going to say there was anything wrong with it. It is what it is. It fits like it is supposed to and it was decent for the price. I'm still using it, just thinking about getting something slightly nicer. When I said it doesn't fit snug, I just meant b/c it is your base silicone case. It stretches to fit around the phone so
when it is in your pocket the corners will sometimes pop loose b/c it has a lot of give to it. For some people it would be fine b/c it is cheap and does the job. Others would hate it. Personal preference I guess. Hope that helps.