I have an Innocase II (dark gray) and the paint is starting to spec off in one of the corners after about 45 days of use. I wrote them an email, and they said my exchange would be accepted, I just had to ship them my case, wait for up to 4 weeks processing, then they would send me a new one.
So, basically, my choices were: stay with the case that I enjoy, but is starting to wear a bit, go naked for a month and take my chances with a toddler that loves to play MiniSquadron (great game) on my phone, or buy another case while I wait for the Innocase to come back, which is pretty stupid, because I dont need a bunch of covers.
I decided to stick it out with the one I got, but I really think that's a dumb move on them. They really should have it work where they take your CC#, ship you a case, and if the return isnt received within 30 days or something, bill your CC for a new case.
While I love everything about the design of the Innocase, I dont love the quality or customer service I have received thus far...