I have long suffered waiting for Froyo and the GPS fix on my Captivate and finally got fed up. Long story short, I got Atrix on day-one after having gotten Captivate day-one also!
This review is a comparison of the pros and cons of the Atrix vs the Captivate. Both unrooted with stock firmware. I have the Atrix fully loaded with the same apps as the Captivate had.
Pros:
I am very happy so far. I will use the 30 day trial to continue to evaluate. If I had to decide today, I would keep the Atrix and put the Captivate on eBay.
John
This review is a comparison of the pros and cons of the Atrix vs the Captivate. Both unrooted with stock firmware. I have the Atrix fully loaded with the same apps as the Captivate had.
Pros:
- Speed. Atrix is fast. Really fast. There is no lag. I had actually gotten used to hitting "home" or "back" on Captivate multiple times before getting a response. Everything is snappy in a way that I had never dreamed of. The market used to take a full minute to show me a list of my apps, now it is 3 seconds. Pandora now comes up and plays almost immediately instead of taking forever. Downloading and installing apps is so fast that I actually LOL. Etc, etc.
- Notification LED. Seems like a small thing, but the lack of this on the Captivate is inexcusable. I leave my phone on vibrate at work and found myself turning the phone on and off MANY times a day just to check for texts, emails and missed calls. This little $0.02 LED makes a huge difference to me.
- Camera Flash. Again seems small, but something I really missed. Wow is it a great flashlight too!
- Fingerprint reader: I didn't even think I would use this! Turns out it is really useful and allows me to easily unlock the phone quickly with one hand - either hand.
- Sync software. Lack of any PC software whatsoever was a major downer with the Captivate. I HATED that Kies is disabled in the US. I connected Atrix to my PC and immediately the proper drivers downloaded and installed to use it as a mass storage device. Next I browsed to the root folder on the phone and low and behold there was a setup.exe file. Running that installed a really nice Windows sync program and all the needed drivers. (Someone at Samsung deserves a swift kick in the balls for Kies.)
- Case design. Atrix is a little smaller than Captivate despite having the same size screen. Something about the more rounded shape just feels better in my hand and smaller in my pocket. The Speck case is awesome BTW.
- Less AT&T bloatware and most can be uninstalled.
- (edit - forgot GPS!) The GPS locks on instantaneously and is extremely accurate. Even sitting on my center console the accuracy is insane. The satellite view showed me centered in the exact parking spot that I pulled into earlier today - I got a strange feeling that it was somehow a live picture from above.
- Screen. Yes the Captivate AMOLED screen is nicer than the Atrix. Hands down. The Atrix does have higher resolution, but the Captivate screen looks sharper, deeper black and has better viewing angles. While doing texting, browsing and other routine tasks there is really very little difference. The time it is most noticeable is when you are looking at fancy live wallpapers and stuff like that.
- Battery monitoring is only accurate to 10% instead of 1% (i.e. 100, 90, 80, 70 etc). WTF?
- Battery. The battery on the Atrix is massive. Considering how much I have used this phone in the past two days, the battery life has been great. It is still too early to say for sure, but it looks like the battery lasts noticeably longer than the Captivate. I noticed the Atrix does not even get hot while playing Robo Defense. The Captivate burned battery like mad on Robo Defense. My guess is the Atrix' Nvidia chipset does not even break a sweat for a simple game like Robo Defense.
- Forward facing camera. Haven't found any software for this yet.
I am very happy so far. I will use the 30 day trial to continue to evaluate. If I had to decide today, I would keep the Atrix and put the Captivate on eBay.
John