Sure you did chief, AT&T's 3G speeds are garbage.
I had a 3GS and at work my speeds would max out ~50kb/s, this is with 5 bars.
My incredible with 1-2 bars in the same spot maxes out 200 kb/s down and 75.4kb/s up.
AT&T more like FailT&T.
I used a few modern phones on ATT and I could NEVER get any decent speeds out of their network, full bars, low bars, different cities, etc......
One day, at the airport, I had to lookup some car rental info.... It literally took almost 15 mins before I just asked every counter if they had my name. I found my reservation by voice before the ATT network could
Also VZ has much better rural penetration for 3G. I can go a few mins out of town and ATT goes to EDGE and is not a pleasant experience. I can drive for hours out of town on VZ and have excellent 3G coverage. It's one of the reasons that Google Nav should never be offered on ATT.
You all can pwn iphone users all day, and you might not even know it!