Sorry I asked for positive comments you sound like Steve Jobs talking about the iphone?
For me.
1 I never noticed timescape using any more battery and yes I did strip it down to facebook, text and emails. I still had to run the fb app and I knew if an email or text came through as it would be in the notification bar.
2 Your right about the all in one part but if Zimly had a picture viewer built into it, it would far out perform Media scape in terms of looks and sound and video playback, it even plays videos in full screen mode when mediascape wont for me that alone blows it out of the water.
3 I still sight Zimly as being a nicer interface and supiror playback quality and the best part is when you delete a file a box pops up saying "Are you sure you wish to cast this file into the firey pits of hell never to return?" Come on how can that be a bad thing? You smile as you delete something, now imagine if it did pictures and when you deleted them pictures of your ex that cheated on you up comes a box saying "Are you sure you wish to cast this file into the firey pits of hell never to return?"
Plus I watch a lot of stuff on my phone either sitting at the beach waiting for the wind or if camping/kiting trip.
4 Not sure what you mean? All media players run through the same amplifier circuit on the phone so mediascape and all other players are the same volume (except one that had a built in frequency booster but it sounded awful) but as I said I did not find any extra battery use.
Your last comment was just an attack at a reasonable quote as that is what most people do anyway so does that class everyone who doesn't like the app clueless?
The only reason for them I can see is it makes it far easier for people coming to Android to do what was always a button press or two away on a normal phone. Well that was how I found it. When I first got the phone the two apps where great but as I started to understand the OS and how apps work and discovered more media apps and finding the fb widget I have not used them as I have found my own way that makes me happy and I find easy.
This is the whole point of Android it's open source so we can all have what we want not be forced to use X Y or Z we can use what ever one we like.