1. Are you ready for the Galaxy S20? Here is everything we know so far!

is there a personal assistant app like siri for android?

Discussion in 'Android Devices' started by mbrazil05, Oct 24, 2014.

  1. mbrazil05

    mbrazil05 Member
    Thread Starter

    Is there an app that offers a "SIRI" like personal assistance experience? Over time i'v e grown fond of using "siri" and found it quite useful in my day to day activities. Does google / android offer anything similar to it?


    My experience with "ok google" has been hit or miss. While I can get it to do a basic task, I cannot get it to really to work as efficiently as I would like (similar to my experience using siri).
     



    1. Download the Forums for Android™ app!


      Download

       
  2. zombdroid

    zombdroid Android Enthusiast

    Can you elaborate?

    I use OK Google on a daily basis. Things like, Navigate To:, Set Reminder:, What is:, Set Alarm, Call: <person in address book>.

    Google Now gives me flight info, shipping information for packages, sports scores and stock updates, weather info, local events, TV listings.

    What are you missing?
     
  3. JimKnuckles

    JimKnuckles Android Enthusiast

    Really?

    Works amazing for me. I use it so many times a day for work. Scheduling, reminders (even location based for when I get home or work or a specific place), send texts, make calls, and emails. It automatically gives my flight info, weather info, scores, traffic updates and news stories I've been following.

    You should go in YouTube or something and look through all the commands and familiarize yourself with google now. I use the Google Now Launcher as well.
     
  4. mbrazil05

    mbrazil05 Member
    Thread Starter

    Ok, i'll bite. I'll concede I may not have a great handle on OK Google and may need to play with it more. So I'll bite and ask.

    Let's say I want to do this with OK google. Can someone walk me thru the commands to say.

    #1. how do I get it to send an txt msg to "Jonnie" that "the work schedule has been changed to Tuesday night"

    #2. How do I get it too open calendar for 25 Oct and make the following entry "call bakery and order 2 dz Halloween cupcakes", close the appointment and make a 2nd appointment for 6pm to "return rental car".




     
  5. Captain Sexy

    Captain Sexy Android Enthusiast

    Install Commander, it works with Google now. This will give you what you want.
     
  6. mbrazil05

    mbrazil05 Member
    Thread Starter

    can you be a bit more specific, I looked up both commander and google commander but did not see if. Can you send a link or give a bit more instruction on where to find the app and how it works?

     
  7. Captain Sexy

    Captain Sexy Android Enthusiast

  8. Caloy

    Caloy Android Expert

    MISS DIVA likes this.
  9. mcbtrain929

    mcbtrain929 Android Expert

    anytime i use ok google and ask it to search something, it always says "can't load search results" when it tries to search after my voice command. my internet is on. is there some option i need to turn on to make these results load? what am i missing?
     
  10. Caloy

    Caloy Android Expert

    I've had the same problem with chrome. For some reason, Chrome wouldn't load when opened from a link like on a google search or facebook.

    I'm currently using next browser, and from time to time it does the same thing, but if it did, I just hit settings and exit, and it would load the links after that.
     
  11. Kalinskym

    Kalinskym Newbie

    There is S Voice, which isn't half bad, you access it by double pressing home button
     
  12. mrsmumbles

    mrsmumbles Android Enthusiast

    For calling and texting I just tell Google to "text so and so" and the text is in progress. I don't use the calendar much, interested in calendar commands also.
     
  13. mbrazil05

    mbrazil05 Member
    Thread Starter

    Ok, I give up. Apparently OK GOOGLE is no true equivalent to "siri" . Now before anyone attack here me out.

    I've had an iphone and used siri extensively. 90% of the time, siri performed the command spoken to it accurately. This has not been the case with "ok google".

    I've look at a ton of videos, read articles, etc, etc but I cannot get OK Google to respond accurately more then 40% of the time. I ve slowed down my speech, mimic what others say they did but nothing seems to work consistently enough. At this point, Ima have to conclude, OK Google is not the one and keep moving from there.

    ps. For those of you who say you get it to work, provide context in what manner you got it too work and what commands you are speaking to it.

    oh yeah I also downloaded a bunch of other android version of siri but they are all flawed.
     
  14. MLSS

    MLSS Android Expert

    I think OK Google is a waste of time a battery. It works about 50% of the time.
     
  15. JimKnuckles

    JimKnuckles Android Enthusiast

    you dont need to install any app to do this...

    if you want to send a text you simply say: Send text to Joe what time are we meeting. Thats it. if you have one or more numbers saved for them, you say Send text to Joe Mobile (or work) waht time are we meeting. you can even say the word question mark and it will place the question mark after your text. same goes for any other punctuation.

    I use this app every single day and it works amazing for me. Do you have your Audio History turned on within the Settings? If not, you need to turn this on for the best functionality.

    watch this video on google now commands and you can see how well it works.. there are also several videos pitting Google Now to Siri, and in every video you'll find Google Now easily outperforms Siri.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2vT0AWDq3DE
     
    LaTuFu likes this.
  16. desmofan

    desmofan Well-Known Member

    I've used Samsung's Svoice for this for the tow + years I've owned my Galaxy S3, and it works brilliantly.
     
  17. AnonGuy

    AnonGuy Android Enthusiast

    Google Now is only marginally useful as an assistant, mostly for search and the few Google Services integrated with it. If you have Search/Location History and Location Reporting Turned off, then Google Now is just about useless.

    S Voice is better if you actually want to do more with external services (Posting to FB/Twitter, for example) or integrate better with the/more apps on the phone (S Note, etc.).

    If S Voice had Siri or Google Now's Speed (or Cortana's Speed), then it would be perfect. Only thing holding it back is the speed to recognize and act on spoken text. Other than that, as an app to interact with the device and its apps, it's superior to Google Now, easily.

    Personally, I think S Voice is more comparable to Siri, while Google Now is more comparable to Cortana. I think Google Now and Cortana are somewhat, fundamentally, a bit different than Siri and S Voice. That's just my opinion. I think the rift between the two types of "assistants" will close as time goes on... But Google and Microsoft's leveraging of their Internet Search Assets has led them to taking a bit of a different method of doing things in that field.

    Cortana and Google now are a lot more about Predictive Search and working off of collected data from your use of Google/Bing and their various services. Siri and S Voice are more vanilla "virtual assistants" that aim to give a better user experience through deeper device/platform integration - which they do accomplish on their respective devices (Galaxy and iPhone devices).

    I think Cortana has a bit of a lead on Google Now because Microsoft develops all the core software for Windows Phone devices, while Google doesn't for most Android devices. Once HTC, LG, Samsung, Sony, etc. replace the Stock Apps (Email, Calendar, Camera, Browser, etc.) it severely limits what Google Now is capable of doing on the device. The OEMs cannot modify Google's "Search" app so there is a wall there and there doesn't seem to be an API surface to properly bridge it - yet.
     
  18. mbrazil05

    mbrazil05 Member
    Thread Starter

    ....Why yes I do have it turned off. Ok ima turn it back on, follow the instructions everyone's instructions and report back on Monday

     
  19. kryptonyt

    kryptonyt Well-Known Member

    I've said this in a few of my other posts: to read and observe the willingness to help others with similar devices and problems that are probably not covered in a manual is very impressive!

    I salute everyone who takes the time to read these posts and then takes the time to give the best answers that may help the person seeking help.

    Reading this particular post; I'm going to give one of these apps a try. I have zero experience with Siri but I do have a number of friends with iphones and they love Siri.

    Thanks again to everyone who gives their time and expertise!:congrats:
     
  20. carme4

    carme4 Member

    Have I got the app for you!!! I'm a 58 year old, not very savvy woman, but I do get on the forums and read a lot and UTTER, which is still in Beta, works in conjunction with Google Now and is GREAT!!! There are so many tutorials and explanations as to how it works via XDA Developers when you tap on the tabs and voice tutorials. You can download an instant launcer so that you don't have to open the app each time. You can keep it on all the time (for instance while driving) and just say "wake up" and it will ask what you need done. You can set it to default to Google Now for help if Utter can't help you. The two together, so far are great for me! It can announce your phone calls and notifications too.
     
    Podivin likes this.
  21. mjwohler

    mjwohler Lurker

    The Assistant I downloaded from the Play store works great.
    One great feature is that it asks you if want it to read an incoming text message.
     
  22. LaTuFu

    LaTuFu Android Expert

    I have only recently begun to use OK Google, since I have been used to old habits of doing everything manually.

    I've not had any trouble using it as an assistant, search tool, etc. I can set appointments, send text/emails,make calls, set reminders, etc. very easily.

    As others have pointed out, make sure to have location services on, and allow OK Google to access your history and train to your voice.

    Props to JimKnuckles video link, that showed me a few things I never thought about using it for.
     
  23. Mikestony

    Mikestony ~30% Carbon Black ±
    VIP Member

    ok, yeah, so I squeegeed a couple posts that really didn't need to be in here.:(
    Keep it civil and respectful and all will be just ducky, cool?

    Thanks and carry on:)
    /thread cleaned....
     

Samsung Galaxy Note 4 Forum

The Samsung Galaxy Note 4 release date was October 2014. Features and Specs include a 5.7" inch screen, 16MP camera, 3GB RAM, Snapdragon 805 processor, and 3220mAh battery.

October 2014
Release Date
0
Reviews
Loading...
Similar Threads - personal assistant app
  1. Michael Zimmers
    Replies:
    8
    Views:
    280
  2. Gireeshma
    Replies:
    4
    Views:
    316
  3. PlayAddagrams
    Replies:
    0
    Views:
    290
  4. furkan25
    Replies:
    3
    Views:
    494
  5. Gireeshma
    Replies:
    0
    Views:
    420
  6. grizmixstir
    Replies:
    3
    Views:
    1,063
  7. nickdalzell
    Replies:
    3
    Views:
    593
  8. Paddy Landau
    Replies:
    8
    Views:
    1,784
  9. Papamalo
    Replies:
    8
    Views:
    2,178
  10. L arry
    Replies:
    6
    Views:
    1,290

Share This Page

Loading...