I disagree. Everything, even if it's unique, is getting chucked into that one massive glob thread. And because of that two things happen
1- most people don't bother to read through everything to see if something has already been posted, because it's just so damn long and jumbled beyond comprehension.
2- because of #1, we are getting tons of duplicate ideas/observations/threads because many people can't keep up with the randomness of the junkpile sticky!