Our website reporting tools break out traffic into all sorts of categories and one is browser and version. We can tell the difference between mobile and desktop browsers pretty easily.
Of course, this can be spoofed but it is reliable overall for analysis.
I don't think it is a stretch for the providers to be able to watch the traffic and toss up a red flag if IE or any other desktop browser is requesting pages on a wireless device.
Just my 0.02
Well - for what it's worth...
Stock Android browser code base is WebKit. HTC adds their features to that. Little known factoid is that you can change the UAString via a debug command/prefs change to "Desktop."
There's a guy with a sig on XDA who when you look at his posts - his sig kind of thumbs his nose and says, ha ha, you are running XXX browser on ZZZ operating system - and admonishes about safe browsing without giving away all of your details.
Works on all my desktop configurations exactly.
Except when I change my HTC browser UAString, he identifies me as running Safari on OS X.
So - I think nj02vette was right, it's about NAT stuff, but again - I knew that tech when it was new, by now you have forgotten all I used to know.
But, I thought you'd find that interesting.
Browser traffic is just one type of data usage, and in the grand scheme of things it doesn't eat up much bandwidth. The data that a carrier would see wouldn't be user agent strings like what identify browsers. There are ways to analyze data so that an ISP or a proxy can do packet shaping among other things. I just don't know how practical or possible it is for someone like VZW to monitor data in this fashion to definitively say it's PC traffic instead of traffic from the device.
EarlyMon, just out of curiosity, were you using one of those "black market" tethering apps, or one available on the regular market?
Gee, I don't know about black market, honestly.
I used the original Wireless Tether as hosted on the Google project servers, so I never thought of that as black market back then.
It's similar looking to - but not evidently the same as, just going by my memory and mind's eye, as - (link deleted by me)
However - that may not even show up for Verizon users. And as nj02vette suggests, may not show up for me soon, either.
I'd read that it had some feature in the one I had to defeat carrier detection - but I wasn't trying to cheat an ISP, I figured I'd try it for grins and pay any price if I crossed a line. I like to tinker around.
But like I said, I just don't see the point anymore.
My phone is already capable of doing what I need my laptop to do when I'm truly mobile, so like I said, for me - why even bother?
A doctor in a remote location needing his laptop to get to a hospital internal web with no dial up around - that's one thing.
Otherwise - I'd rather use my laptop less, not more.
If anyone offered a good wireless service where I live - kind of the boonies - where I could drop my DSL line and just do the whole house off a hotspot - sure, I'd pay for that in a heartbeat.
Broadband is everywhere, root tether seems like an ultra-niche to me right now.
And sadly, from what I've read in other forums, it's for the script kiddies to get something for nothing, and I don't roll that way.
OK - off soapbox, hope I answered the question.
Upvote
0