I added my review to the Rogers web page for the HTC Magic. I'm not holding my breath that they'll actually posy it, of course. ;-)
"The HTC Magic is a beautiful, slick phone. It fits perfectly in the palm of your hand, looks sexy, feels sexy, and is sure to impress. Call quality is great, and it is just amazing to have what really amounts to a little computer with you all the time with the usefulness of Google's Android operating system, and applications from the Android Market Place.
Unfortunately the Rogers Magic only comes with version 1.5 of the operating system (think of the phone as being like a little computer, like your PC with Windows Vista on it) which is now out of date. Google released version 1.6 back at the beginning of October, and version 2.0 is coming out now on phones around the world, just not in Canada. Rogers claims HTC won't be releasing an update to 1.6 for this phone, which means users won't be able to get the added functionality of the updated operating system. In fact, there are now applications (little programs for the phone, just like on an iPhone) in the Android Market Place that won't work on this phone because they require version 1.6.
As amazing as this phone is, you should wait until the new phones come to Canada with the newer version of the Android Operating System."
I gave it 3/5 stars and said that I would NOT recommend this phone to a friend.